When Someone Sees You Before You See Yourself || All the Bright Places - Review & How It Would Make You Feel That "You've Got at Least a Thousand Capacities Spring Up in You"
Film Review / 2020 / Netflix
When Someone Sees You
Before You See Yourself
All the Bright Places - Review & How It Would Make You Feel That
You've Got at Least a Thousand Capacities Spring Up in You
"A movie that worked on me. I don't fully know why. And maybe that's the point - it's one of the stories that don't ask you to watch them. They ask you to feel them."
Spoiler Warning
"This review discusses the full story of All the Bright Places (2020), including its ending. If you haven't watched it yet - honestly, go watch it first. It is worth it. Come back after."
I haven't published a blog about a movie in a while. Not one of those - "I just watched this and I need to write about it right now" kinds of posts. But a few hours ago I watched All the Bright Places, and I'm writing this while I'm still inside it. The feelings are strong and I want to keep it that way - raw, unfiltered, still shaking a little.
Let me be honest. I almost didn't think this movie would get to me. The opening few minutes had me like - I'll enjoy it, but it won't fully have me. But it got me. It got me hard.
What It Is, What It's Really About
All the Bright Places follows two teenagers in a small Indiana town - Violet Markey, a popular girl quietly drowning in survivor's guilt after losing her older sister in a car accident, and Theodore Finch, a boy labelled a "freak" by everyone around him, obsessed with death and desperately trying to hold himself together. They first meet on a bridge ledge - both there for reasons they don't fully admit. That opening scene is doing a lot of work. It is the small moments that make the biggest difference when someone finds themselves in the darkest place.
Their school project sends them exploring the small wonders of Indiana together. And through that - slowly, unevenly, sometimes uncomfortably - they pull each other back toward something that feels like living.
The first half is about Finch helping Violet come out of her shell. Getting her back on her bike, back in the car, back into the world, back into writing. It feels warm and hopeful. Then the second half quietly flips it. Violet starts seeing what everyone around Finch has refused to see - that he is not okay. That he hasn't been okay for a long time. And the tragedy is not just that he suffers, it is that nobody around him - not even Violet, not even us watching - understood the full weight of it until it was too late.
The story knows exactly what it is. It knows when it is being melodramatic and when it is being devastating. The movie is sympathetic and well-meaning but also honest. That balance is rare, and they executed it too well.
How It Was Made
The movie is technically well made. Brett Haley directed this, and Jennifer Niven co-wrote the screenplay alongside Liz Hannah - with Niven being the original author of the book. The fact that the author adapted her own work matters here. There is a care in how the story is told that doesn't feel like a studio product.
The film's visual design and direction received consistent praise for its understated palette and tonal pacing. Cinematographer Rob Givens keeps the Indiana landscape quiet and vast - small towns, open skies, and a lot of trees and water. It contrasts the internal noise of these two characters in a way that works without being on-the-nose.
Haley's first question in development was "what are we doing in this genre differently" - and that self-awareness comes through on screen.
Justice Smith as Finch is doing something genuinely difficult - playing someone who is charming and magnetic on the surface, deeply broken underneath, and keeping both things equally true at the same time. Depicting any type of mental illness is touchy territory, but the sincere and measured approach, starting with the young actors, leads to an authenticity that is crucial to our investment.
Elle Fanning as Violet keeps things grounded. She could have played this character as purely a victim and it would have gone schmaltzy fast. She doesn't. She was brilliant - her crying, her sadness, her grief, she will make you feel it too. As Finch said, "You are all the colours in one, at full brightness." Elle Fanning was literally that on screen.
The music by Keegan DeWitt - gentle piano, ambient texture - never tries to tell you how to feel. It just sits with you. I appreciated that.
The silence, though. The moments where they just look at each other, or sit next to each other, go to places, do things and we see them doing all of that - those are the best scenes in the film. No dialogue, no exposition. Just presence. Finch and Violet at their most honest.
What This Movie Is Really Arguing
This is the part I want to spend time on.
Mental illness is invisible until it isn't - and by then, it is often too late.
The novel shows that mental illness can be profoundly isolating. Author Jennifer Niven has confirmed that Finch has undiagnosed bipolar disorder. By eighth grade, Finch had begun to suspect he wasn't real - and when he confided in a friend about it, that friend turned on him and dubbed him "Theodore Freak." That is where it starts. Not with the illness alone - but with the world's response to it. The film rests on the notion that you never really know what others are going through - that people who seem to have it all together on the outside might have a lot more going on underneath.
I thought I understood what Finch was going through - bullying, reputation, isolation. But there is more to it. His father's physical violence and emotional neglect are among the root causes of his disorder, and the bullying only deepened an already fragile psychological state. Niven uses terms like "Awake," "Long Drop," and "Asleep" to describe the cycles of his mood, and as his "Long Drop" draws closer, tension builds around Finch's frame of mind - while he simultaneously teaches the grief-stricken Violet how to live hers. That parallel - him saving her while falling apart himself - is the core tragedy.
Finch's bipolar disorder has two episodes: manic and depressive. The effects on his daily life include irritability, aggressiveness, and intense feelings of guilt. The manic phase is when we first love him - energetic, romantic, literary, alive. The depressive phase is when the world loses him. And the film gives you both, so you understand why nobody quite caught it in time.
There were issues with Violet too - she was also in her lowest phase when Finch met her. He helped her come out of all of it, pushed her even when she said no. Only if somebody had done the same for him, before it was too late.
Grief takes more forms than we recognize.
Violet's grief over her sister is visible, clean, easy to label. Finch's suffering has no accepted language around it. Both are real. Both are debilitating. The film treats them with equal weight, which is one of the things it genuinely gets right.
The question of emotional dependency - and whether helping someone can also trap them.
This one is complicated, and I will be honest - I am conflicted about it.
Finch rescues Violet in the first half. Gets her back into the world. And she becomes better because of him. But there is a version of this that is not healthy - where helping someone becomes a way of making them need you, where their dependency becomes your purpose. Is someone using another person's low emotions to make them vulnerable, to create that need in them, that want? The film seems aware of this. It doesn't fully resolve it, but it is aware of it - and it was exactly this tension that made me think the movie wouldn't work for me early on. The way they handled it, though, it stopped being an issue.
Here's the hard truth: Finch needed help too. He was pouring into Violet while he was emptying himself. Violet tries helping him but she realizes that even when she is there for him, it is still his battle. That is not a failure on her part. It is a reality about mental illness that the movie has the honesty to show - that love is not enough, that presence is not enough, that some battles require professional intervention that neither Violet nor anyone around Finch pushed hard enough for.
That is uncomfortable. It is meant to be.
"I feel a thousand capacities spring up in me."
Virginia Woolf - The WavesThere is also an interesting question here about curiosity, need, and connection.
Virginia Woolf once wrote, "Why are women so much more interesting to men than men are to women?" The quote appears in this story's orbit and it made me think. Virginia had this quote regarding men seeing women as objects or endless mystery to be studied, classified, controlled. I don't think it is about objectification or the idea of women as some endless mystery to be studied and classified. I think it is about something simpler and more human - that men, broadly, are more restless in their want. They know something is missing and they chase it, sometimes clumsily. Women tend to be more emotionally complete, or at least more settled in their emotional knowledge. Men want that - that warmth, that completeness - desperately and eagerly. Finch wanting to give everything to Violet, to see her fully, to help her back into light - it fits this. It is not about control. It is about that ancient human longing to be needed by the right person and to need them back. The movie never says this directly, but it breathes inside it.
Wonders, small places, and the act of paying attention.
Their school project - finding the small wonders of Indiana - becomes the structure of the film's second act. It is not a gimmick. It is an argument. That life is worth living not because of some grand revelation but because there are small, specific, beautiful things in every ordinary place if you choose to look. Finch teaches Violet to look again. It is the most generous thing one person can do for another.
The Personal Part
I said at the start that I almost didn't expect this movie to reach me. I'll tell you why - it opened like every other emotionally manipulative teen romance. Boy sees depressed girl, boy enters her life, girl gets better, emotional strings start playing. I have seen that framework before. It can be lazy. It can be exploitative.
But they played it differently. There is a self-awareness in the writing that keeps it from feeling manipulative. The movie knows it is dealing with real things - not using mental illness as a plot device, but actually sitting inside it. And then the second half earns everything the first half was building.
I cried. I got emotional. The movie got me in a way I was not fully prepared for.
The moments that got me most weren't the big dramatic ones. It was the quiet moments. Finch and Violet sitting together saying nothing. Them going to the "what I want to do before I die" wall and writing their thoughts without saying anything. The look on his face when he thinks nobody is watching. The way Violet's voice changes when she starts writing again. The film's frank talk about mental illness, suicidal thoughts, physical abuse, and family loss is so potent and necessary. Nothing felt decorative.
Is it a perfect movie? No. The pacing in the first half drags slightly. The supporting characters - especially the school peers - are thin. A film that views a girl finding hope from a boy can become cumbersome at times, and yes, there are moments where it risks that. Violet's narration at the end - summarizing what just happened - underestimates the audience. We got it. We didn't need it explained.
But here is the thing. All the Bright Places is not asking you to grade it. It is asking you to feel it. And it felt.
The quotes in the notebook I have kept now - Virginia Woolf, Cesare Pavese, Jennifer Niven herself - i felt them all alive while I was watching this. "We do not remember days, we remember moments." And I will remember the moment of watching this movie long after everything else fades. A film that sends you back to your favourite quotes and makes them feel new again is doing something right.
Not perfect. But damn, it worked.
Go watch it. Don't grade it. Don't analyse it while it's happening.
Just sit with it. Let it find you. It will.
Comments
Post a Comment